Home / Linguistics / A CRITICAL EVALUATION OF TWO OF THE THEORIES OF LANGUAGE ACQUISITION: (BEHAVIOURISM AND MENTALISM)

A CRITICAL EVALUATION OF TWO OF THE THEORIES OF LANGUAGE ACQUISITION: (BEHAVIOURISM AND MENTALISM)

 

Table Of Contents


Title page   —       –       –       –       –       –       –       –       –       –       – i    

Declaration —       –       –       –       –       –       –       –       –       –       -ii

Approval page —   –       –       –       –       –       –       –       –       –       -iii

Dedication —         –       –       –       –       –       –       –       –       –       -iv

Acknowledgement —       –       –       –       –       –       –       –       –       -v    

Table of content   —         –       –       –       –       –       –       –       –       -vi                 Abstract —   –       –       –       –       –       –       –       –       –       –       -vii


Thesis Abstract

Abstract
Language acquisition has been a topic of significant interest and debate in the fields of psychology, linguistics, and education. Two prominent theories that have been proposed to explain how individuals acquire language are behaviourism and mentalism. This research project aims to critically evaluate these two theories in terms of their strengths, weaknesses, and implications for understanding the process of language acquisition. Behaviourism, as advocated by B.F. Skinner, posits that language acquisition is primarily a result of environmental stimuli and conditioning. According to behaviourist principles, individuals learn language through imitation, reinforcement, and shaping. Proponents of behaviourism argue that all aspects of language, including grammar and syntax, can be explained by these mechanisms. However, critics of behaviourism point out its limitations in accounting for the creative and generative aspects of language use, as well as the rapidity with which language is acquired by children. In contrast, mentalist theories of language acquisition, such as Noam Chomsky's Universal Grammar, propose that humans are biologically predisposed to acquire language and that there are innate cognitive structures that facilitate this process. Mentalist theories emphasize the role of internal mental processes, such as cognition and problem-solving, in language acquisition. Proponents of mentalism argue that the complexity and creativity of language use cannot be explained solely by external stimuli and reinforcement. This research project will examine the empirical evidence supporting both behaviourism and mentalism, including studies on language development in children, neuroimaging research, and cross-linguistic studies. By critically evaluating these theories, this project seeks to provide insights into the underlying mechanisms of language acquisition and the factors that contribute to individual differences in language learning. Additionally, this research will explore the practical implications of behaviourism and mentalism for language teaching and educational practices. Understanding the strengths and limitations of these theories can inform educators and policymakers in designing effective language instruction programs that cater to diverse learning styles and abilities. In conclusion, a critical evaluation of behaviourism and mentalism in the context of language acquisition can provide valuable insights into the complex interplay between environmental influences, cognitive processes, and biological predispositions in shaping how individuals learn language. By considering the implications of these theories for educational practices, this research aims to contribute to the ongoing dialogue on effective language teaching and learning strategies.

Thesis Overview

1.1       Background Statement

Language forms the fundamental function of communication. As social beings, we use it as our medium of communication to help us communicate with people that live both within and beyond our regional/geographical locations just as it is the case that other people from within and outside our environment do communicate with us. Language occurs almost wherever we come into contact with other people and will be different according to the nature of the contact. It is noted that our lives take us through a succession of activities requiring the use of language. The activities are very diverse and, what ever dialect we speak, have specific feature of language associated with them. Many activities are connected with our jobs. One may be an engineer giving instructions to a draughtsman; a lawyer advising a client; a trade union official discussing fringe benefits; a bus conductor collecting transport. Fares; A sergeant instructing a soldier; or a scientist reading a technical report. Other activities are part of our leisure. We may be playing tennis, football, or

9


volley ball. Or relating to our home life, we may be acting as a mother, a father, a husband, a wife, a son or a daughter.

To acquire language in the actual sense seems to depend on the linguistic atmosphere in which the child is brought up. Skinner (1957) stresses that language is not a mental phenomenon but a behavioral one. Alllen and Burren (1971:135) hold the view that language is essentially an adventitious construct, taught by conditioning or drill and explicit explanation,, or by built-up elementary data processing procedures. “language acquisition is controlled by the condition under which it takes place and that as long as individuals are subject to the same conditions they will learn the same way”, (Wilkins, 1972:169-4). This might be the reason why a child raised in Hausa speaking community will acquire Hausa language. One brought up in China acquires Chinese and vice verse incase that happens to take place.

It is worth to note that there are linguists that do not give much emphasis to the linguistic atmosphere that language learner/acquirer finds himself; but rather stress much emphasis on a learners’/acquirer’s innate language learning/acquiring capacity. According to Atchison (1989,p.55) ‘Human are genetically imprinted with knowledge abut language”. This claim seems to have gone inline with the observation made by Fodor

10


(1974), Bever and Garrett (1974) who stressed that training a dog to walk on its hind legs does not prejudice the claim the bipedal gait is genetically coded in humans. “The fact that human begins can learn/acquire to whistle like a lark does not prejudice the species-specificity of birdsong” Fodor, Bever and Garrett (12974, p. 451).

With these claims in mind therefore, it might be right to assume that other animals’ inability to talk, acquire or learn language in its actual sense supports the assumption that language is restricted to human race alone.

The aim of the study is to establish the fact that language is so important to human beings that we can not exist without it as the medium through which we transact all our worldly affairs I equally intend to establish that there is a need for all of us (students of English language to realize that there exists distinction between language acquisition and language learning. Then I finally want to state that in this project, I will critically examine some of the theories of language acquisition. The views of mentalists and behaviorists are specifically the ones that will be discussed in this write up.

11


1.2       The Purpose of the Study.

In this project I intend to explore and discuss, very critically, some of the theories of language acquisition. In essence, particularly aim to critically examine the strengths and weaknesses of behaviorists and mentalists theories before we eventually state our stand. The project topic has been given different titles in different periods, suggesting angles and different foci by different people especially scholars of linguistics and psycholinguistics. However, I am of the view that the plausibility of their words needs to be accepted or rejected on marital basis. It is with that fundamental objective in mind I decided to undertake this project.

I hope among other things that some of the important contributions of this research work would include additional knowledge or all theories of language acquisition, provide additional data on language acquisition research works especially those that’s elected and critically examine Behaviorists and mentalists views. I hope it would equally assist towards contributing to the growing literature on acquisition/learning of language generally.

1.3   The Objectives of the Study

The objectives of the study are:

12


(1)         To critically evaluate two of the theories of language acquisition and learning (Behavourism and Mentalism).

(2)         To explore the extent to which behaviouralist and mentalist theories of language acquisition influence in acquisition of language.

1.4   THE DELIMITATION/SCOPE OF THE STUDY

The project, due to time and space factors, will only attempt to critically discuss two theories of language acquisition/learning with special attention or contrastive Analysis of the behaviorist and mentalist theories.

1.5   METHODOLOGY APPLIED

In the course of this project, both primary and secondary source materials would be used. I would mainly make use of fact gathered from text books, periodicals and consultations with the project supervisor, lecturers, colleagues and friends who seem to have got reasonable quality and quality data materials that could help make this project a big success.


Blazingprojects Mobile App

📚 Over 50,000 Research Thesis
📱 100% Offline: No internet needed
📝 Over 98 Departments
🔍 Thesis-to-Journal Publication
🎓 Undergraduate/Postgraduate Thesis
📥 Instant Whatsapp/Email Delivery

Blazingprojects App

Related Research

Linguistics. 4 min read

The Influence of Social Media on Language Evolution: A Corpus-Based Study...

The project titled "The Influence of Social Media on Language Evolution: A Corpus-Based Study" aims to explore the impact of social media on the evolu...

BP
Blazingprojects
Read more →
Linguistics. 2 min read

Analysis of Language Variation in Online Communication Platforms...

The project titled "Analysis of Language Variation in Online Communication Platforms" aims to investigate the diverse linguistic patterns and variatio...

BP
Blazingprojects
Read more →
Linguistics. 3 min read

An Analysis of Language Variation in Social Media Discourse...

The project titled "An Analysis of Language Variation in Social Media Discourse" aims to investigate the diverse linguistic features and patterns foun...

BP
Blazingprojects
Read more →
Linguistics. 4 min read

An Analysis of Code-Switching Patterns Among Bilingual Speakers in a Multilingual Co...

The research project, "An Analysis of Code-Switching Patterns Among Bilingual Speakers in a Multilingual Community," seeks to investigate and understa...

BP
Blazingprojects
Read more →
Linguistics. 3 min read

Analyzing the Impact of Code-Switching on Bilingual Communication in Multilingual So...

The research project titled "Analyzing the Impact of Code-Switching on Bilingual Communication in Multilingual Societies" aims to investigate the phen...

BP
Blazingprojects
Read more →
Linguistics. 2 min read

The Influence of Social Media on Language Evolution and Change...

The project titled "The Influence of Social Media on Language Evolution and Change" aims to explore the dynamic relationship between social media and ...

BP
Blazingprojects
Read more →
Linguistics. 2 min read

The Impact of Code-Switching on Language Development in Bilingual Children...

Research Overview: The research project titled "The Impact of Code-Switching on Language Development in Bilingual Children" aims to investigate the e...

BP
Blazingprojects
Read more →
Linguistics. 4 min read

The Influence of Bilingualism on Cognitive Processing in Children...

The research project titled "The Influence of Bilingualism on Cognitive Processing in Children" aims to investigate how bilingualism affects cognitive...

BP
Blazingprojects
Read more →
Linguistics. 4 min read

The Impact of Code-Switching on Bilingual Language Development...

The research project titled "The Impact of Code-Switching on Bilingual Language Development" aims to investigate the effects of code-switching on the ...

BP
Blazingprojects
Read more →
WhatsApp Click here to chat with us